nicholas-creamery-logo_edited.png

SMALL BATCH

ICE CREAM

Nicholas Creamery was born out of a love for homemade ice cream, handcrafted recipes and a desire to take something we all know and love and bring it back to its purest form.

We hand-make small batch ice cream and ice cream cakes using the purest of ingredients and collaborate with local businesses to showcase the best products in New Jersey. We are 100% in love with small town livin'-- nothing makes us happier than serving up scoops and smiles to the incredible communities that have welcomed our sweet vision with open hearts (and spoons!).

Scooper-pic.jpg

ALWAYS CHANGIN' UNIQUE FLAVORS

Every week a new flavor pops up.

Every season we bring back the fan faves. 

Which gives you every reason to come back

again

and again

 and again.

The Creameries feature the classics (Valrhona Chocolate and Tahitian Vanilla) while churning out delicious, creative flavors including: Hudson Café Coffee Crunch, Bourbon Chocolate Chunk, Nutty Monkey, Malted Cookies N Milk, and Vegan Coconut Cherry Vanilla.  Pick your ice cream & add your toppings, or choose from one of our carefully curated options, always made to order.

have your cake

AND EAT IT TOO

Have you ever tasted an ice cream cake made with HOMEMADE ice cream and made from scratch ingredients? Hold onto your spoons because Nicholas Creamery brings this classic favorite to a whole other level of delicious. Grab and go cakes are available in all Nicholas Creamery locations.

Baileys-milkshake.jpg

CREAMY, DREAMY MILKSHAKES

Here's what's shakin'... our handspun milkshakes! We take our small batch flavors and give them a whirl with milk and a whipped cream topper. These tried and true classics have Creamery fans screaming (and sippin'!) from the rooftops!

BOOK A 

 creamery CART

Roll in the Nicholas Creamery experience to your next event! Our beloved ice cream carts travel to your door offering your choice of four homemade ice cream flavors, three toppings, cups/ spoons and a Nicholas Creamery on site. Perfect for backyard parties, weddings, showers, school celebrations or corporate events.

OUR LOCATIONS

With 3 locations under our belt (which keeps getting tighter with every new flavor), we are always dreaming up something new. Be sure to check back to see if we pop up near you!

84 1st Avenue
Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716
732-204-2340

Hours:

Sun-Sat:

12PM to 10:30PM

586 River Road
Fair Haven, NJ 07704

732-852-2033

Hours:

Sun-Sat:

12PM to 10PM

1201 Sycamore Ave
Tinton Falls, NJ 07724
848-456-4035

Hours:

Sun-Sat:

12PM to 10:30PM

444 Ocean Blvd N
Long Branch, NJ 07740

732-272-1098

Hours:

Mon-Thur:

12PM to 10:30PM

Fri & Sat:

12PM to 11:00PM

IMG-3516_edited.jpg

#NICHOLASCREAMERY

@NICHOLASCREAMERY

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
Tahitian Vanilla Scoop_edited.jpg

“They give you so much ice cream and toppings which I really appreciate, most places skimp on you. Their ice cream is to die for, the best I've had in my life! You absolutely need to go!” 

—  Jill G.