SMALL BATCH

ICE CREAM

Nicholas Creamery was born out of a love for homemade ice cream, handcrafted recipes and a desire to take something we all know and love and bring it back to its purest form.

We hand-make small batch ice cream and ice cream cakes using the purest of ingredients and collaborate with local businesses to showcase the best products in New Jersey. We are 100% in love with small town livin'-- nothing makes us happier than serving up scoops and smiles to the incredible communities that have welcomed our sweet vision with open hearts (and spoons!).

ABOUT

ALWAYS CHANGIN' UNIQUE FLAVORS

Every week a new flavor pops up.

Every season we bring back the fan faves.

Which gives you every reason to come back

again

and again

and again.

The Creameries feature the classics (Valrhona Chocolate and Tahitian Vanilla) while churning out delicious, creative flavors including: Hudson Café Coffee Crunch, Bourbon Chocolate Chunk, Nutty Monkey, Malted Cookies N Milk, and Vegan Coconut Cherry Vanilla. Pick your ice cream & add your toppings, or choose from one of our carefully curated options, always made to order.

FLAVORS

@alixearle Jersey will always have your back girl 👀🍒

Feeling a little old fashioned and A LOT in the mood for pure deliciousness? Turn the volume up and the cravings on with a Handspun Shirley Temple milkshake. 😋 🍒🔊

Nicholas Creamery’s Shirley Temple Milkshake is made with homemade small-batch Shirley Temple ice cream (sweet cream, grenadine swirl, lotsa cherries & lemon+lime zest) , blended with milk, topped with whipped cream and finished with a cherry on top.

📍 Wall: 2435 Route 34, Manasquan
📍 Middletown: 1500 Route 35
📍 Fair Haven: 560 River Rd
📍 Atlantic Highlands: 84 First Ave
📍 Tinton Falls: 1201 Sycamore Ave
📍 Long Branch: 444 Ocean Ave (opens at 5pm)
🥄 North Brunswick Coming Spoon!

#nicholascreamery #shirleytemple #asmr

It’s Nicholas Creamery cart season and the calendar is filling up. Book now for weddings, graduation parties, corporate events, birthday parties, backyard events and more.

Follow us @nicholascreamery.

For pricing info & availability- email carts@nicholascreamery.com.

#nicholascreamery

First we start with homemade, small-batch perfection. The toppings? That’s where things get all kinds of fun. 🍨🎉

Brownie chunks, cookie dough pieces, made from scratch sauces, rainbow sprinkles, chocolate sprinkes cherries and endless ways to make your scoop one of a kind.

Get in here and load up… we are open til 9pm.

#nicholascreamery #smallbatchicecream #icecreamtoppings

For our Nicholas Creamery X @rutgersu Honey Lavender 🍯 collab we suited up and visited the Rutgers Cooperative Extension bee hives to source honey directly from their beekeeping program at Rutgers University.

Yes, Nicholas wore the gear.
Yes, we looked official (courage questionable).
And for the record… not one sting.

What Rutgers is building is something special… connecting university research, local agriculture and community needs across all 21 counties in New Jersey.

Every spoonful of this small batch Honey Lavender ice cream (always a fan favorite!) is a sweet reminder that a whole lot of good is growing right here in the Garden State 🫶🏻

#nicholascreamery #gardenstate #rutgersuniversity

Nicholas Creamery’s Shirley Temple… stealing the spotlight 🍒.

Homemade Sweet Cream ice cream, grenadine ripple, chopped maraschino cherries and fresh lemon + lime zest. Bright, creamy, fizzy and honesty… one of our favorite flavors we’ve ever made. 🫶🏻

Walk in from Noon-10pm and grab a pint

Two NEW Homemade, small batch flavors for the weekend!

🍒Shirley Temple 🍒
A little retro. A little sweet. A little extra. This is a proper Shirley Temple… Nicholas Creamery style.
Homemade, sweet cream ice cream loaded with grenadine ripple, chopped maraschino cherries and lotsa fresh lemon & lime zest. It tastes bright, has a hint of fizz and cushions it all with blast after blast of creamy cherry goodness.

🐝Rutgers U Honey Lavender 🍯
For our small batch HONEY LAVENDER - we collabed with @rutgersu to purchase honey directly from the Rutgers Cooperative Extension - a beekeeping class at Rutgers University.
After infusing lavender into our small batch ice cream and swirling in tons of Rutgers U honey- we BEE- lieve this is the best batch of Honey Lavender we’ve ever made!! A sweet reminder of how much good is growing right here in the Garden State.

Now Scooping at all locations!
🍨 84 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands
🍨 586 River Road, Fair Haven
🍨 1201 Sycamore Ave, Tinton Falls
🍨 444 Ocean Ave, Long Branch
🍨 1500 Route 35, Middletown
🍨 2435 Route 34, Manasquan
🍨 North Brunswick, Coming Spoon

Two new flavors drop this weekend.
If you guess both right, honestly, you deserve a sweet little something…🍦😏.

First 2 people to nail both flavors correctly = e-gift card on us for a free scoop 🫶🏻😘

Give us your best guess.

#nicholascreamery

All smiles under pressure and dangerously good with a scoop. Whoever says the younger generation doesn’t know how to hustle has never met the Nicholas Creamery crew- best 🍦 team in the biz. 🫶🏻

#nicholascreamery

We can try every new flavor… but somehow, the classics still call our name. 🍦

There’s something about Nicholas Creamery’s Cookies N Cream, our just-the-right-touch-of-mint Mint Chocolate Chunk, or our bestselling loaded Brown Sugar Cookie Dough that just tastes like home. Familiar, comforting, and always exactly what we need. 🫶🏻

📍 Fair Haven, Tinton Falls, Long Branch, Middletown, Wall, Atlantic Highlands
🥄 North Brunswick Coming Spoon

All locations are open from 5-9pm for Easter Sunday. Tell your peeps!! 🐥 😉

📍 Wall: 2435 Route 34, Manasquan
📍 Middletown: 1500 Route 35
📍 Fair Haven: 560 River Rd
📍 Atlantic Highlands: 84 First Ave
📍 Tinton Falls: 1201 Sycamore Ave
📍 Long Branch: 444 Ocean Ave (opens at 5pm)
🥄 North Brunswick Coming Spoon!

#nicholascreamery #smallbatchicecream #eastersunday

Consider this your official Easter weekend order 🐰🥤 A Nicholas Creamery Handspun Carrot Cake Shake filled to the brim with homemade Carrot Cake ice cream and topped with made-from-scratch wet walnuts. Don’t overthink it… just get it.

And while you’re at it don’t forget to stock up on Easter 4 for $29 Pints, Ice Cream Pies, and all your other small batch favorites in Fair Haven, Atlantic Highlands, Tinton Falls, Long Branch, Wall, and Middletown!

We will be open on Easter Sunday from 5pm - 9pm!

#nicholascreamery #carrotcake #milkshake

The Nicholas Creamery Pint Sale is officially ON and it’s eggs-actly what your Easter needs including homemade Carrot Cake and Toasted Coconut Ice Cream! 🐰🎉

The Easter bunny isn’t the only one bringing treats this weekend 🧺 Grab your favorite HOMEMADE, small batch flavors, ice cream pies, and gift cards .…perfect for baskets, brunch, or straight-from-the-pint spoonfuls.

Through Easter Sunday- pints are (4) for $29 + tax in all locations.

📍 Wall: 2435 Route 34, Manasquan
📍 Middletown: 1500 Route 35
📍 Fair Haven: 560 River Rd
📍 Atlantic Highlands: 84 First Ave
📍 Tinton Falls: 1201 Sycamore Ave
📍 Long Branch: 444 Ocean Ave (opens at 5pm)
🥄 North Brunswick Coming Spoon!

#nicholascreamery #homemadeicecream #eastertreats

24 hours later… our Long Branch location is OPEN.

Our thoughts are with everyone affected by yesterday’s accident. A huge thank you to the (Long Branch Fire Department), @longbranchfire @longbranch_police_department, EMTs and volunteers.

Thank you to Vinny at @sciortino.tailors and Andy from L&M Pavers who stepped in, lead the charge and helped us get back on our feet so quickly. We owe you a whole lotta soft serve. 🍦🙏✨😉

We are open until 9pm tonight and 4 for $29 Easter pint sale starts today.

#nicholascreamery

EASTER PINT SALE: 4 for $29 starts TODAY and the flavor you’ve all been asking for is officially back… CARROT CAKE 🥕🍰

This fan favorite is made with homemade cream cheese ice cream, chunks of made-from-scratch carrot cake, with handfuls of walnuts for that classic carrot cake flavor in every bite. Sweet, spiced, creamy, and back just in time. 🐰

Stop by and stock up on your Easter favorites before they’re gone.

📍 Wall: 2435 Route 34, Manasquan
📍 Middletown: 1500 Route 35
📍 Fair Haven: 560 River Rd
📍 Atlantic Highlands: 84 First Ave
📍 Tinton Falls: 1201 Sycamore Ave
📍 Long Branch: 444 Ocean Ave (opens at 5pm)
🥄 North Brunswick Coming Spoon!

#nicholascreamery #carrotcake #eastertreats

2026 Ice Cream Wars Results 🍦🏆

77 schools
580 pounds of gummy bears eaten
2,141 three-gallon cans of ice cream consumed

Nicholas Creamery donated $27,078.63 back to local schools.

One very clear takeaway: when Jersey schools rally, they do it loud, proud and incredibly sweet 🫶🏻

To every student, teacher, school admin and family who came through our doors... THANK YOU for making this March the best ever. We loved meeting so many new faces and seeing so much good ole fashioned fun.... you melted our ice cream hearts more than you will ever know.

Who won?
Watch the video 🎥

Xoxo,
Nicholas Creamery

#nicholascreamery #icecreamwars #homemadeicecream

IT’S ALMOST EASTER! 🐰 Be the ultimate host (or guest!) and bring Nicholas Creamery Ice Cream Pies to your Easter table. 🐣

🪱 Dirt N’ Worms Ice Cream Pie- Chocolate cookie crust filled with made from scratch cookies and cream ice cream topped with whipped topping and decorated with Oreo crumbs and gummy worms!!!

🥜 Peanut Butter Ice Cream Pie- Graham cracker crust filled with small batch Peanutbutterpalooza ice cream topped with vanilla whipped topping and decorated with a housemade salted peanut butter drizzle and made from scratch fudge drizzle!!!

Hop to it and come see us in Fair Haven, Atlantic Highlands, Tinton Falls, Long Branch, Wall, and Middletown!

Ps. We will be open on Easter Sunday from 5pm - 9pm!

#nicholascreamery #easterpie #icecreampie

Sunday is Sunday-ing and you’ve got nothing but time. These March flavors are leaving soon… which creamy, dreamy small batch scoop are you choosing for last licks?

1) Peanut Butter AF (as fuddggggeee)
2) Cotton Candy
3) Cherry Vanilla
4) Heavenly Hash

Homemade.
Small Batch.
Jersey Love 🫶🏻

Walk in Noon-9pm.

#nicholascreamery #monmouthcountynj #nj #newjersey

The more you know… 🌈 🌟 If you walk in and see a long line, don’t panic … we’ve got you. If you’re just here to grab pints or anything from the To Go freezer, you don’t have to wait with everyone else.

Skip the line, head straight up to the register, and be on your way with your favorite pints, pies or cakes in hand.

Consider it your Fast Pass… nothing should stand between you and your small batch ice cream 😉

Middletown (1500 Route 35), Fair Haven (586 River Road), Atlantic Highlands (84 First Ave), Tinton Falls (1201 Sycamore Ave), Wall (2435 Route 34) and Long Branch (444 Ocean Ave N). North Brunswick Coming Spoon!

#nicholascreamery #homemadeicecream #smallbatchicecream

Peanut Butter AF (As Fuuudddgggge, relax 😜)

Housemade chocolate ice cream loaded with peanut swirl, Reese’s Pieces, and peanut butter cups. Trust us… one bite and this just might become your new #1 best-in-class emotional support pint.

Pint PSA: If you’re only here for pints or anything from the To Go freezer, do not stand in line… you can head straight to the register like the VIP you are. 😎

📍84 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands
📍586 River Road, Fair Haven
📍1201 Sycamore Ave, Tinton Falls
📍444 Ocean Ave, Long Branch
📍1500 Route 35, Middletown
📍2435 Route 34, Wall
🥄 North Brunswick, Coming Spoon

#nicholascreamery #homemadeicecream #peanutbutterlovers

Suns out, cones out ☀️🍦 Warm weather, blue skies, and homemade ice cream in hand… it doesn’t get better than this.

Small-batch scoops were made for days exactly like today 🤍 Go get your cones!

📍Middletown, Wall, Atlantic Highlands, Long Branch, Tinton Falls, Fair Haven
🥄 North Brunswick Coming Spoon

#nicholascreamery #homemadeicecream #icecreamcones

It’s a milkshake kind of day, New Jersey ☀️ Thick, creamy, handspun goodness is calling your name!

MINT WITH ALOTTA CHIP
Mint choc chunk ice cream, more chocolate chips, whipped cream & hot fudge drizzle, 🍒

RAINBOW & CLOUDS
Rainbow & Clouds ice cream, milk, whipped cream, 🍒

OOEY GOOEY PEANUT BUTTER
Peanutbutterpalooza ice cream, homemade peanut butter sauce, peanut butter cups, whipped cream, hot fudge drizzle, whipped cream & 🍒

🥤Wall: 2435 Route 34, Manasquan
🥤Middletown: 1500 Route 35
🥤Fair Haven: 560 River Rd
🥤Atlantic Highlands: 84 First Ave
🥤Tinton Falls: 1201 Sycamore Ave
🥤Long Branch: 444 Ocean Ave
🥄North Brunswick Coming Spoon!

#nicholascreamery #milkshakes #homemadeicecream

Want to know how serious Ice Cream Wars has gotten? This little legend showed up at 13 HOURS old. 👶🍦

Officially our youngest Ice Cream Wars participant ever… and honestly, the bar keeps getting more awesomely ridiculous by the day.

We’ve seen principals behind the counter, mascots working the room, cheerleaders rolling deep, grandparents pulling up, and now… newborns entering the competition before they’ve even learned how to focus their eyes. 😭

At this point, if your school thinks it’s winning, just know… everyone else thinks they are too.
And based on what we’re seeing? Nobody is backing down.

Because around here, bragging rights apparently start at birth. 😏🏆🍦One week to go until we find out the WINNER… Let’s DO THIS PEOPLE!!! ❤️

#nicholascreamery

FLAVOR ALERT 🚨 Homemade VEGAN CHOCOLATE is here! Non dairy chocoholics- we got you.

Chocolate 🍫 Vegan 🌱 Delicious 🤤 Worth grabbing a pint (or four!) for your home freezer! ✔️

Fair Haven (586 River Road), Atlantic Highlands (84 First Avenue) Tinton Falls (1201 Sycamore Ave), Middletown (1500 Route 35), Long Branch (444 Ocean Ave), and Wall (2435 Route 34). North Brunswick Coming Spoon!

#nicholascreamery #veganchocolate #veganicecream

These flavors may come with stories… and definitely a few “back in my day” moments 😋

Meet the Old Man Series… a love letter to old school ice cream 🍨 Butter Pecan, Pistachio, Black Raspberry Chocolate Chunk & Cherry Vanilla… slow churned, extra creamy, and packed with that extra lovin’

No shortcuts. No nonsense. Just like Pop Pop 🤍

📍84 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands
📍586 River Road, Fair Haven
📍1201 Sycamore Ave, Tinton Falls
📍444 Ocean Ave, Long Branch
📍1500 Route 35, Middletown
📍 2435 Route 34, Wall
🥄 North Brunswick, Coming Spoon

#nicholascreamery #classicflavors #homemadeicecream

Say hello to TWO new flavors now available at ALL locations!! 🍒🍫

🍒 Cherry Vanilla- Homemade sweet cream ice cream packed with sweet dark cherries for that perfect classic-meets-dreamy bite!!

🍫 Heavenly Hash- A chocolate lovers dream with decadent dark chocolate ice cream, homemade marshmallow swirl, chocolate-covered almonds, and chocolate chunks in every scoop!!

Basically… you can’t choose wrong 😌

Middletown (1500 Route 35), Fair Haven (586 River Road), Atlantic Highlands (84 First Ave), Tinton Falls (1201 Sycamore Ave), Wall (2435 Route 34) and Long Branch (444 Ocean Ave N). North Brunswick Coming Spoon!

#nicholascreamery #cherryvanilla #heavenlyhash

One thing these Scooper Events keep reminding us?

We are surrounded by some seriously incredible teachers, principals and admin. We just wish everyone could see what we see at every one of these events.✨

We see school leaders showing up with genuine love for their students and pride for their schools- high fiving, joking, cheering, laughing and making memories right alongside the kids.🍦

The joy on the students faces when they see their principals and teachers behind the counter? Just THE BEST.

It’s what makes Ice Cream Wars bigger than ice cream. 🏆

And honestly… we’re just lucky to witness it every day. ❤️

To all of you who work tirelessly to teach, guide and give your hearts to the kids of Monmouth County- thank you for all you do 🙏

#nicholascreamery #icecreamwars #teacherappreciation

Week 2️⃣ Ice Cream Wars Update:

37 Schools (out of 75 total)
10,282 Customers
Smiles & Licks: ∞

At this point, we need to ask…
Are you schools okay? 😅

Snowstorms, cheerleading squads and nuns scooping ice cream (respectfully and honestly? iconic). .. Week 2 had range and we are LIVING for it!!

You all showed up like this was less of a scooper event and more of a full-blown campaign for glory. 👏👏

We saw cheer squads arrive like they were headed to nationals.
Mascots working the room like local celebrities.
Parents ordering like they were preparing for a storm.
Students high fiving and treating homemade ice cream like a competitive event.
And nuns behind the counter scooping with serious focus and elite technique. 🙌

Honestly… some of you are taking this alarmingly seriously and we respect it. 🫶🏻

People keeping asking… are we revealing who’s leading?
Absolutely not. 😉

But if your event is still coming up, just know this:

The bar is no longer on the floor. The bar is somewhere in the atmosphere.🚀

There’s an Ultimate Prize.
And based on what we’ve seen so far… nobody came to casually participate.

Week 3 and we expect even more chaos. Giddy up folks, this ice cream doesn’t eat itself. You’ve got work to do. 😎

XOXO
Nicholas Creamery

Some came for school spirit. Some came for ice cream. Some came because they were told nap time could wait. 😜

Every Ice Cream Wars champion had to start somewhere.🍦👶

Small Batch. Small Humans. Big Energy.

#nicholascreamery #icecreamwars #homemadeicecream

.pro-gallery-wix-wrapper {display: block !important;} .pro-gallery-wix-wrapper .gallery-item-container {opacity: 1 !important; display: block !important;}

Follow us on Instagram

@nicholascreamery

have your cake

AND EAT IT TOO

Have you ever tasted an ice cream cake made with HOMEMADE ice cream and made from scratch ingredients? Hold onto your spoons because Nicholas Creamery brings this classic favorite to a whole other level of delicious. Grab and go cakes are available in all Nicholas Creamery locations.

ORDER

CREAMY, DREAMY MILKSHAKES

Here's what's shakin'... our handspun milkshakes! We take our small batch flavors and give them a whirl with milk and a whipped cream topper. These tried and true classics have Creamery fans screaming (and sippin'!) from the rooftops!

BOOK A

creamery CART

Roll in the Nicholas Creamery experience to your next event! Our beloved ice cream carts travel to your door offering your choice of four homemade ice cream flavors, three toppings, cups/ spoons and a Nicholas Creamery on site. Perfect for backyard parties, weddings, showers, school celebrations or corporate events.

BOOK NOW

OUR LOCATIONS

With 6 locations under our belt (which keeps getting tighter with every new flavor), we are always dreaming up something new. Be sure to check back to see if we pop up near you!

FAIR HAVEN

586 River Road
Fair Haven, NJ 07704

732-852-2033

Hours:

Sun-Thurs:

12PM to 9PM

Fri- Sat:

12PM to 10PM

LONG BRANCH

444 Ocean Blvd N
Long Branch, NJ 07740

732-272-1098

Hours:

Sun-Thurs:

12PM to 9PM

Fri-Sat:

12PM to 10PM

ATLANTIC HIGHLANDS

84 1st Avenue Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716
732-204-2340

Hours:

Sun-Thurs:

12PM to 9PM

Fri-Sat:

12PM-10PM

MIDDLETOWN

1500 Route 35
Unit 19
Middletown, NJ 07748

848.225.3476

Hours:

Sun-Thurs:

12PM to 9PM

Fri -Sat:

12PM to 10PM

TINTON FALLS

1201 Sycamore Ave
Tinton Falls, NJ 07724
848-456-4035

Hours:

Sun-Thurs:

12PM to 9PM

Fri-Sat:

12PM to 10PM

WALL

Wall Town Centre

2435 Route 34

Unit 11

Manasquan, NJ 08739

732.612.3027

Hours:

Sun-Thurs

11AM to 9PM

Fri-Sat:

11PM to 10pm

#NICHOLASCREAMERY

@NICHOLASCREAMERY

“They give you so much ice cream and toppings which I really appreciate, most places skimp on you. Their ice cream is to die for, the best I've had in my life! You absolutely need to go!”

— Jill G.

SMALL BATCH

ICE CREAM

ALWAYS CHANGIN' UNIQUE FLAVORS

Every week a new flavor pops up.

Every season we bring back the fan faves.

Which gives you every reason to come back

again

and again

and again.

​

Follow us on Instagram

have your cake

AND EAT IT TOO

CREAMY, DREAMY MILKSHAKES

creamery CART

OUR LOCATIONS