Hudson Coffee Crunch.png
 

HANDMADE, ALL NATURAL, SMALL BATCH ICE CREAM

ATLANTIC HIGHLANDS & FAIR HAVEN

 

 

Nicholas Creamery was born out of Nicholas Harary's love for all natural, high quality ingredients, handcrafted recipes, and a desire to take something we all know and love and bring it back to its purest form. 

We're handmaking small batch ice cream using natural dairy and working directly with local farmers and food artisans to source the freshest, seasonal ingredients. We serve made to order waffle cones prepared the old fashioned way - a hot waffle maker and a quick flick of the wrist.

The Creameries feature the classics (Valrhona Chocolate and Tahitian Vanilla) while churning out delicious, creative flavors including: Hudson Café Coffee Crunch, Kentucky Pig (Nicholas Reserve 1792 Bourbon, Bacon and Valrhona Chocolate), Shipwreck Bananas Foster, and Vegan Coconut Cherry Vanilla.  Pick your ice cream & add your toppings, or choose from one of our carefully curated options, always made to order.

Nicholas Creamery has scoop shops in both Atlantic Highlands and Fair Haven, New Jersey.

 
creamery_mission_statement copy.jpg

ATLANTIC HIGHLANDS

84 1st Avenue
Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716

732-204-2340

Hours:

Monday through Thursday

3PM to 9PM

Friday: 3PM to 10PM

Saturday: 12:30PM to 10PM 

Sunday 12:30PM to 9PM 

FAIR HAVEN

586 River Road
Fair Haven, NJ 07704

732-852-2033

Hours:

Monday through Thursday

3PM to 9PM

Friday: 3PM to 10PM

Saturday noon to 10PM

Sunday noon to 9PM

 

Nicholas creamery menu

We hand make all of our ice cream in small batches using all natural, seasonal ingredients. We're always thinking up new flavor combinations and experimenting with the classics, so this is just a sample of our menu. 



 The GOAT (goat cheese ice cream, roasted strawberries & balsamic reduction)

The GOAT (goat cheese ice cream, roasted strawberries & balsamic reduction)

rhys.jpeg
 “Ooey Gooey Peanut Butter Milkshake”

“Ooey Gooey Peanut Butter Milkshake”

 Shipwreck Bananas Foster Ice Cream

Shipwreck Bananas Foster Ice Cream

 Salted Caramel Cone (salted caramel ice cream, chocolate chips & waffle cone bits)

Salted Caramel Cone (salted caramel ice cream, chocolate chips & waffle cone bits)

FullSizeRender.jpg
 Kentucky Dreaming (Nicholas Reserve Four Roses Bourbon & brown sugar) 

Kentucky Dreaming (Nicholas Reserve Four Roses Bourbon & brown sugar) 

 Hudson Café Coffee Crunch (hazelnuts & coffee)

Hudson Café Coffee Crunch (hazelnuts & coffee)